Reading Wars: The $1 BILLION Industry That's Failing Students
Schoolutions: Curious Educators. Evidence-Based Strategies. Classrooms Where Every Child Thrives.
01/09/23
•72m
About
Comments
Transcript
Featured In
Are reading wars destroying our children's education? In this eye-opening conversation, Dr. P.L. Thomas, a former high school English teacher with 18 years of classroom experience, exposes how education strategies, effective teaching, and instructional strategies are being replaced by one-size-fits-all programs that ignore what we know about student engagement, student motivation, and inclusive teaching.
What You'll Learn:
✅ Why the reading wars keep repeating every decade (it's not what you think!)
✅ The REAL reasons Mississippi's reading scores improved (hint: it's not just phonics)
✅ How teacher autonomy is being destroyed by scripted programs
✅ Why balanced literacy isn't the enemy educators claim it is
✅ The hidden costs of over-labeling students with reading difficulties
Perfect for:
- Teachers struggling with mandated reading programs
- School administrators seeking evidence-based solutions
- Parents questioning their child's reading instruction
- Education coaches supporting teacher development
- Instructional leaders wanting to understand the research
Key Topics Covered:
- Teacher coaching and professional development alternatives
- Culturally responsive teaching vs. scripted curricula
- Equity in education and inclusive classrooms
- Student success through empowered educators
- Education transformation and teacher impact
- School change that prioritizes thriving students
This conversation challenges the narrative that phonics-only instruction is the solution to literacy challenges, instead advocating for inspired teaching that meets individual student needs through innovative teaching practices and teacher support.
CHAPTERS
0:00 - Introduction: Meet Dr. P.L. Thomas
2:15 - The Inspiring Teacher That Changed Everything
5:30 - Teacher Autonomy: Then vs Now
8:45 - The Reading Wars: Core Problems Explained
15:20 - Historical Context: 1940s to Today's Third Reading War
22:30 - Mississippi's Reading Gains: The Real Story
28:10 - England's Phonics Mandate: What Really Happened
32:45 - Defining Reading in the 21st Century
38:20 - Workshop Teaching vs Scripted Programs
45:15 - The Role of Standards and Assessment
50:30 - What Counts as "Scientific" Research?
57:40 - Media Influence and Market Forces
64:25 - Supporting Students with Reading Difficulties
70:10 - Building Community and Resistance
75:30 - Hope and Action Steps for Educators
78:45 - Final Thoughts: Putting Students First
- Paul’s Recent Publications & Essays in Edited Volumes
- Individuals Paul Mentions During This Episode
- Sold a Story Podcast
- No Child Left Behind (NCLB)
- National Education Policy Center (NEPC)
- National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP)
- National Reading Panel (NRP)
- Decoding Dyslexia
- Orton-Gillingham
When coaches, teachers, administrators, and families work hand in hand, it fosters a school atmosphere where everyone is inspired and every student is fully engaged in their learning journey.
Previous Episode
Why This Teenager's Approach to Digital Literacy is Genius
January 2, 2023
•43m
Meet Olivia "Liv" Van Ledtje, the remarkable 15-year-old who transformed her experience with bullying into a global movement for digital literacy and student empowerment. In this inspiring conversation, discover how one student's journey from victim to victor is revolutionizing education and changing how we think about student engagement, classroom behavior, and the power of student voices.
🎯 What You'll Learn:
• How to turn difficult students into empowered educators through passion-based learning
• Revolutionary approaches to student motivation and classroom engagement that work
• Digital citizenship strategies that inspire rather than intimidate students
• Building authentic teacher-student connections that transform classroom culture
• Creating inclusive classrooms where every student voice matters
• Innovative teaching methods that spark student participation and active learning
✨ Key Takeaways for Educators:
Liv's story proves that effective teaching starts with believing in our students. Her journey from a bullied third-grader to an international speaker demonstrates the transformative power of student-centered education, culturally responsive teaching, and a pro-kid mindset. Whether you're dealing with disruptive students, low engagement, or seeking fresh education strategies, this conversation offers hope and practical solutions.
Chapters
0:00 - Introduction: Meet 15-Year-Old Global Speaker Liv
2:15 - From Bullying Victim to Confident Creator
5:30 - The Birth of Liv Bits: Turning Pain into Purpose
8:45 - Inspiring Educators Who Changed Everything
12:20 - The Power of Teacher-Student Connections
16:10 - Gaming in Education: Changing Minds at NCTE
19:25 - Digital Literacy Without Fear: A New Approach
23:40 - Heart Beeps: Creating Emotional Connection
27:15 - Humanity and Activism in Education
31:50 - Keynote Speaking Around the World
36:20 - Pop-Tarts and Authentic Connections (Fun Segment!)
40:15 - The Importance of Digital Crews and Safety
44:30 - Hashtags and Building Your Brand
48:45 - Block and Bloom: Handling Online Negativity
52:20 - Feedback as Fuel for Growth
56:35 - Spotlights: Lifting Others Up
60:10 - Technology Beyond Assessment
63:25 - Spark Hope, Story, and Action
67:40 - Future Projects: STEAM Club and Long Liv Books
72:15 - The Meaning of "Refulgent" - A Beautiful Story
75:30 - Final Thoughts and Call to Action
Episode Mentions:
- Spark Change: Making Your Mark in a Digital World
- 30 Under 30 Award - International Literacy Association
- Digital Literacy
- Padlet, Flip (formerly Flipgrid), and Seesaw
- Rebecca Woods - Health IT
- Midwest Education Technology Community (METC) Conference
When coaches, teachers, administrators, and families work hand in hand, it fosters a school atmosphere where everyone is inspired and every student is fully engaged in their learning journey.
Next Episode
5-Minute Math Conferences That Create Independent Problem Solvers
January 16, 2023
•46m
Transform your math classroom with 5-minute conferring strategies that build confident, independent mathematicians! In this episode of Schoolutions, I interview Dr. Gina Picha, author of "Conferring in the Math Classroom," to reveal how brief, intentional conversations can revolutionize student engagement, student motivation, and mathematical thinking.
Discover how to shift from answer-focused instruction to identity-building practices that create empowered educators and thriving students. Learn the difference between "within task" and "beyond task" conferences, master questioning techniques that inspire students rather than funnel thinking, and build a classroom culture where every child sees themselves as a mathematician.
Perfect for teachers, education coaches, instructional leaders, new teachers, and anyone seeking effective teaching strategies that support the whole child through innovative teaching approaches.
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction to Math Conferring
2:30 What is Math Identity?
8:45 Comparing Literacy vs Math Conferences
15:20 Conference Structures: Within vs Beyond Task
22:10 The Power of Questioning in Math
28:40 Asset-Based vs Deficit-Based Teaching
35:15 Building Strong Math Communities
42:30 Developing Mathematical Conjectures
48:20 Creating Independent Problem Solvers
Episode Mentions:
- Gina’s Book: Conferring in the Math Classroom: A Practical Guidebook to Using 5-Minute Conferences to Grow Confident Mathematicians
- Brian Bushart
- Jennifer Bay-Williams
- Gina Kling
- Kathy Richardson
- Lucy Calkins
- Lev Vygotsky and Zones of Development
- National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) - Principles to Actions: Ensuring Mathematical Success for All (2014)
- Marian Small
Gina’s Recommended Resources:
- Three Benefits of Math Conferences in Elementary School
- Recognizing and Alleviating Math Anxiety
- Assessing Basic Fact Fluency
#MathEducation #ElementaryMath #TeachingStrategies #StudentEngagement #MathConferring #ClassroomManagement #ProfessionalDevelopment #EducationPodcast #MathIdentity #InstructionalCoaching #TeacherTraining #StudentSuccess #MathAnxiety #EffectiveTeaching #ElementaryEducation
When coaches, teachers, administrators, and families work hand in hand, it fosters a school atmosphere where everyone is inspired and every student is fully engaged in their learning journey.
If you like this episode you’ll love
Promoted