Yvonne Menke: Secrets in St. Croix Falls
Crime Exposé Podcast with Nancy O'Dell
04/23/26
•19m
About
Comments
St. Croix Falls, Wisconsin : In St. Croix Falls, the quiet routine of a small-town morning is shattered when 45-year-old Yvonne Menke is gunned down just steps from her home. The brazen, close-range attack shocks the tight-knit community, where nearly everyone knows the victim or her family. With few clues at the scene, investigators are left piecing together a crime that feels both deeply personal and disturbingly calculated.
As detectives dig into Yvonne’s life, attention turns to those closest to her, uncovering complicated relationships and simmering tensions beneath the surface. A potential love triangle and strange behavior from those in her orbit raise suspicions, but without hard evidence, the case becomes a frustrating puzzle. Despite strong community rumors about who might be responsible, proving it is another matter entirely.
Years pass, and the investigation grows cold, leaving Yvonne’s family without answers and a town haunted by what many believe is an open secret. Decades later, fresh eyes revisit the case, reexamining overlooked details and long-standing suspicions—offering a renewed chance to uncover what really happened on that tragic morning.
Follow Us On :
Instagram : @crimexpodcast
TikTok : @crimexpod
Hosted By Nancy O'Dell
Instagram : @NancyODell
Previous Episode
The Final Broadcast of Kumba Sesay
April 20
•19m
HOUSTON, TEXAS : A rising radio host in Houston is found dead under disturbing circumstances, her body discovered far from where the crime actually occurred. With no identification at the scene and few immediate clues, investigators must first piece together who she was before they can begin to understand what happened to her. Surveillance footage soon reveals a chilling glimpse of how her body was disposed of, suggesting a calculated and deeply personal act.
As detectives dig into her life, they uncover a driven and ambitious woman with a growing public presence—and a complicated personal world. But as they retrace her final days, tensions, strained relationships, and hidden conflicts begin to surface, complicating the investigation.
When key leads stall and initial suspects are ruled out, the case becomes a frustrating puzzle. Then, just as momentum begins to fade, a crucial tip shifts the direction of the investigation—offering a new perspective on what may have unfolded and bringing detectives closer to the truth behind a brutal and baffling crime.
Follow Us On :
Instagram : @crimexpodcast
TikTok : @crimexpod
Hosted By Nancy O'Dell
Instagram : @NancyODell
Next Episode
Ventura, California : In Ventura, a gruesome discovery on a remote hillside sets off a haunting investigation when the body of 42-year-old Danelle Claus is found brutally beaten. With little more than a crime scene and a suspected weapon nearby, detectives are left to reconstruct her final moments and determine how she ended up in such an isolated place.
As investigators retrace her last known movements, they uncover a complex picture of Danelle’s life—marked by resilience, personal struggles, and a recent effort to rebuild. A fleeting encounter with an unknown man the night before her death becomes a key lead, but with no witnesses and few immediate clues, the case quickly stalls.
Years turn into decades as the investigation goes cold, leaving her family without answers. But advances in forensic science and renewed determination from investigators breathe new life into the case, offering a chance to finally uncover what happened on that lonely hillside.
Follow Us On :
Instagram : @crimexpodcast
TikTok : @crimexpod
Hosted By Nancy O'Dell
Instagram : @NancyODell
If you like this episode you’ll love
Promoted