The Deltona Disappearance: Jimmy Schaefer
Crime Exposé Podcast with Nancy O'Dell
03/23/26
•19m
About
Comments
Deltona, Florida: When 36-year-old limousine driver and father James “Jimmy” Schaefer fails to return home after work, his sudden disappearance sends his family into a panic. Known for always staying in touch, Jimmy instead sends a series of strange text messages suggesting he may have skipped town. As the days pass with no sign of him, worried relatives report him missing and investigators begin searching for answers.
Detectives retrace Jimmy’s final movements, questioning coworkers, friends, and anyone who may have seen him that night. His vehicle is discovered where he left it for work, but his phone is gone and his whereabouts remain a mystery. As investigators dig deeper into Jimmy’s life, they uncover troubling details about financial struggles, risky behavior, and relationships that raise new questions about who might have wanted him gone.
In this episode of Crime Exposé with Nancy O’Dell, a puzzling missing persons case takes a shocking turn, uncovering secrets that ultimately reveal a crime far more disturbing than anyone could have imagined.
New Episodes Every Sunday Night and Wednesday Morning
Watch this episode and subscribe to our youtube channel here :
https://www.youtube.com/@CrimeExposePodcast
Follow Us On :
Instagram : @crimexpodcast
TikTok : @crimexpod
Hosted By Nancy O'Dell
Instagram : @NancyODell
Previous Episode
The Edgewater Bridge Mystery: Melissa Lee
March 18
•19m
Bothell, Washington: In a quiet suburb just northeast of Seattle, a mother returns home late at night expecting to find her 15-year-old daughter asleep. Instead, she discovers the front door kicked in, furniture overturned, and signs of a struggle inside the family home. Her daughter, Melissa Lee, is nowhere to be found.
Hours later, a horrifying discovery beneath a nearby bridge confirms every family’s worst fear. Melissa’s death sends shockwaves through the community and launches an urgent investigation as detectives try to determine who could have targeted the teenager and how they gained access to her home.
In this episode of Crime Exposé with Nancy O’Dell, investigators sift through rumors, personal connections, and hidden clues from Melissa’s life as they race to identify a predator before anyone else becomes a victim.
New Episodes Every Monday and Thursday Morning
Watch this episode and subscribe to our youtube channel here :
https://www.youtube.com/@CrimeExposePodcast
Follow Us On :
Instagram : @crimexpodcast
TikTok : @crimexpod
Hosted By Nancy O'Dell
Instagram : @NancyODell
Next Episode
The Deadly Romance: Jocelyn Peters
March 25
•19m
St. Louis, Missouri: When 30-year-old elementary school teacher Jocelyn Peters is found brutally murdered in her apartment, the shocking crime sends ripples through her tight-knit community. Known for her warmth, ambition, and deep love for her students, Jocelyn was seven months pregnant and preparing for a future she had carefully planned, making her death all the more devastating.
In the wake of the tragedy, investigators begin unraveling the final days of Jocelyn’s life. What initially appears to be a devoted partnership quickly reveals cracks beneath the surface, secrets, deception, and mounting tension that raise troubling questions.
As detectives dig deeper, inconsistencies in suspects stories begin to emerge. Surveillance footage, conflicting timelines, and suspicious behavior point to a far more complex situation than a random act of violence. With each new discovery, the case takes unexpected turns, exposing a web of lies that stretches beyond what anyone could have imagined.
In this episode of Crime Exposé with Nancy O’Dell, a seemingly senseless murder evolves into a chilling investigation where truth is buried beneath manipulation, and the pursuit of justice reveals just how far someone might go to protect their secrets.
New Episodes Every Monday and Thursday Morning
Watch this episode and subscribe to our youtube channel here :
https://www.youtube.com/@CrimeExposePodcast
Follow Us On :
Instagram : @crimexpodcast
TikTok : @crimexpod
Hosted By Nancy O'Dell
Instagram : @NancyODell
If you like this episode you’ll love
Promoted